
How trim-and-respond strategies, fault detection, and better zone feedback can improve building automation system performance.
Sometimes the biggest problems in a building start with something surprisingly small.
During a recent Stuck on a Bucket webinar, an attendee shared an experience many controls technicians could appreciate. A single VAV damper had become mechanically stuck open. Its position feedback continued reporting 100%, and the building’s control system responded in a way that affected more than just that one zone.
How can a system designed to respond intelligently to building conditions end up making things worse?
The answer has a lot to do with the information we’re asking our building automation systems (BAS) to trust.
From Fixed Setpoints to Demand-Based Control
Traditionally, many commercial HVAC systems operated with relatively fixed supply air static pressure setpoints. The air-handling unit maintained a predetermined pressure while individual variable air volume (VAV) boxes adjusted their dampers to regulate airflow into occupied spaces.
When building demand decreases, the air handler may continue maintaining more static pressure than the zones need. Dampers close to restrict airflow, while the supply fan works harder than necessary.
Think of it as keeping the water pressure high throughout a building even when most of the faucets are barely open.
Static pressure reset offers a more responsive approach. Rather than maintaining one constant pressure setpoint, the system uses information from downstream VAV zones to adjust the pressure setpoint as demand changes.
The U.S. Department of Energy identifies static pressure reset as an opportunity to improve air-side system efficiency.
Source: U.S. Department of Energy — Building Management System Replacement
One strategy for accomplishing this is called trim-and-respond.
How Trim and Respond Works
The idea behind trim-and-respond control is straightforward: Give the building what it needs without continuously providing more than necessary.
In a static pressure reset application, the control system gradually reduces the static pressure setpoint while monitoring whether downstream zones can meet their airflow requirements. When sufficient requests indicate that additional pressure is needed, the system responds by increasing the setpoint.
This approach is included in ASHRAE Guideline 36, which establishes standardized high-performance sequences of operation for HVAC systems. These sequences are intended to improve energy efficiency, system performance, control stability, and fault detection and diagnostics.
Source: ASHRAE — Standards and Guidelines
But there’s an important consideration: The control system needs to distinguish between a legitimate request for additional capacity and a problem that only looks like one.
When One Zone Becomes the Problem
Consider the stuck damper from our webinar.
Depending on the control sequence, its reported position could influence the system’s response. If the programming interprets that condition as an unmet need for additional pressure, the air handler may increase its pressure setpoint even though the underlying issue is mechanical.
A damper reporting 100% open might indicate that a zone needs more airflow. But it could also point to an actuator or linkage issue, an airflow problem, or another condition that additional supply pressure won’t resolve.
For the technician troubleshooting the system, that’s an important distinction. Increasing fan pressure may not fix the problem; it could simply make the system work harder.
Feedback Versus Demand: Knowing What the Data Means
Damper position and zone demand are related, but they aren’t necessarily interchangeable.
Damper position tells us how far the damper is reported to be open. A zone demand signal communicates whether the zone’s control logic is requesting additional heating, cooling, or airflow capacity.
Both provide useful information, but their roles in the control sequence must be clearly defined.
For example, a system might monitor damper positions to identify abnormal behavior while using appropriately defined zone requests to influence a reset strategy. Damper position itself can also play an important role in static pressure reset sequences.
Guideline 36 provides methods for weighting requests from different zones through importance multipliers, allowing designers to account for differences in how zones should influence system-level decisions.
The appropriate approach depends on the building’s design, equipment, and operating requirements. Selecting and validating the right inputs helps ensure that control decisions reflect actual system needs.
Fault Detection: When the Building Tells Us Something Is Wrong
The same information used to control equipment can also help identify problems.
Suppose one VAV damper consistently reports a position near 100% while most other zones are satisfied. That pattern may indicate an unusually high load, insufficient airflow, or a mechanical problem worth investigating.
This is where trending and fault detection and diagnostics (FDD) become useful. Rather than waiting for a comfort complaint or an obvious equipment failure, technicians can use operational data to identify unusual behavior and investigate its cause.
Guideline 36 includes fault detection and diagnostics provisions intended to support more consistent identification of operating problems.
Of course, more alarms don’t automatically mean better troubleshooting. Useful diagnostics provide context: What’s happening? Where is it happening? How long has it been happening? And what should we investigate first?
The goal is to turn building data into information technicians can act on.
Putting Better Feedback to Work with KMC Conquest®
During the webinar, KMC Controls Vice President of Business Development Jesse Shoemaker and Sales Engineer Greg Salisbury explored how KMC Conquest controllers can support practical applications of these control concepts.
Depending on the controller and application, embedded VAV controller points can communicate requests for colder supply air, warmer supply air, or additional static pressure. These signals can be collected and evaluated as part of a broader system-level control strategy.
Additional programming can help integrators develop application-specific sequences and diagnostic functions.
The KMC Conquest VAV controller family is designed for variable air volume terminal units, while the broader KMC Conquest automation hardware lineup includes programmable controllers for air-handling and other HVAC equipment applications.
For a refresher on VAV operation, see The 101s: Intro to VAVs.
Having capable controllers doesn’t automatically make an installation compliant with Guideline 36. Appropriate sequences must still be selected, programmed, and commissioned according to project requirements.
Five Questions Worth Asking Before Implementing Static Pressure Reset
Whether you’re designing a new sequence, commissioning a system, or troubleshooting an existing installation, these questions can help guide the process.
- Can we trust the inputs? Verify that sensors, damper feedback, and communication points are operating correctly before relying on their data.
- Are we using the right signals? Determine whether the specified sequence should respond to damper position, airflow demand, or another defined request.
- What happens when something goes wrong? Consider how the system should respond to stuck dampers, communication failures, or persistent requests for additional capacity.
- Can we recognize recurring problems? Use trending to identify zones that consistently behave differently from the rest of the system.
- Have we tested the sequence under realistic conditions? Commissioning should verify that the system responds appropriately as demand changes and when relevant faults occur.
These considerations can help technicians reduce troubleshooting time, avoid unnecessary adjustments, and improve confidence in system operation.
Better Control Starts with Better Information
A single damper position, an unusual trend, or a persistent request for additional capacity might seem like a small detail. But in a connected building automation system, those details can influence equipment serving an entire facility.
ASHRAE Guideline 36 provides a framework for developing more consistent, responsive HVAC control sequences. Reliable feedback, thoughtful programming, and useful diagnostics help turn those strategies into practical results.
Ultimately, the goal isn’t just to make the building respond. It’s to help the building respond for the right reasons.
Explore the KMC Conquest solutions page for product information and technical resources.
For more discussion about applying Guideline 36 concepts in real-world systems, watch our November Stuck on a Bucket webinar featuring Jesse Shoemaker and Greg Salisbury.